I saw a post on MakeUseOf about 11 Tools to Easily Rip Your DVDs & Blu-Rays to Your Computer, and I do agree with Mark that VLC is an easy solution for ripping DVDs and converting videos. I used it on my PC and Mac to check the correct DVD title for ripping. But I’m afraid I have to disagree with Mark O’Neill on most of the other tools because what he recommended is limited, and I believe there are better programs for DVD and Blu-ray ripping and video converting. Besides, most of the 11 tools mentioned by Mark are for Windows only. There are better choices for Mac users. And I decided to share my opinions on those Bluray and DVD rippers as well as my recommendations or alternatives about what I think are the best Blu-ray DVD Rippers, especially for macOS users, including the new releases from Apple: the ARM-based Silicon chip Macs and the new macOS 13 Ventura.
Comments on MakeUseOf's Recommendations
Below are my detailed options on Mark’s recommendations on MakeUseOf. As I have never heard about Aurora, I don’t have any comment on it. I see most of the contents were written by Mark in 2017, and now it’s 2023!
MakeMKV does a great job decrypting protected DVDs and Bluray discs and produces multiple audio and subtitle tracks MKV files. And, MakeMKV is always free for DVDs. You just have to get your new beta key every month. Along with Handbrake, it works perfectly for me to compress DVDs to H264 with multiple audio and subtitle tracks to MP4 so you can turn the subtitle on or off.
But I’m not too fond of MakeMKV as I don’t understand why it offers 4 or 5 titles selected for ripping, all of which are over 90 minutes. Obviously, a DVD cannot be over 360 minutes long, and I assume MakeMKV cannot select the right title for ripping, or it’s not sure. So it lists all possible titles, and users have to make the decision themselves.
Also, you will still have to re-convert the MKV file for a more friendly format if you want to watch movies on your iPad/iPhone and Apple TV.
If you want to back up your Bluray disc, MakeMKV is no longer free but $50 for a lifetime subscription.
Handbrake can be a great tool if it can do better jobs for encrypted movies, especially for Blu-ray ripping. And if there are more profiles, it can meet more people’s needs. Generally, Handbrake is better for normal users than MakeMKV, and it is cross-platform for Linux, Windows as well as macOS. For the majority of people, we recommend using MakeMKV to decrypt the DVD and recode it to MP4 with Handbrake.
If you are in trouble with the Handbrake crashing during encoding, please check my guide here; I’m sure it can help. Please don’t rip your DVD to 1080P. It won’t give you any better quality.
WinX DVD Ripper Mark listed is the free version. However, when I download the latest so-called free version from the official site, it actually downloads the trial of the platinum one. And, as far as I can see, the free version is really limited for the out video formats, and it’s unable to handle copy-protected DVDs either. So, I don’t recommend trying the free version of WinX DVD Ripper.
Instead, the platinum version, WinX DVD Ripper Platinum, is more powerful with many output formats and supports Disney DVDs. Also, WinX DVD Ripper Platinum says itself to be the fastest DVD ripper as WonderFox does. I see they have the same profile copying DVDs to MPG without re-coding. And it is fast in copying! It is worth a try.
Freemake Video Converter
Freemake Video Converter was a free video converter and DVD ripper, and I’d always like to recommend it to people looking for freeware on Reddit. However, it’s no longer free and fails to start up on my machine. I tried everything I could, but it still did not work. Below is just an error when I tried to re-download the latest version.
DVDShrink WAS great, but the latest version is Version 184.108.40.206 – 25 July 2004. See! 14 years ago! It is still working well on Windows XP and Windows 7. But I see users complaining it’s non-compatible with the latest Windows 8/8.1 and Windows 10. If you still want to shrink DVDs, I’d like to recommend DVDFab DVD Copy, Leawo DVD Copy, or Magic DVD Copier.
I recommend AnyDVD HD over AnyDVD since AnyDVD HD can do everything AnyDVD does and copies Blu-rays. RedFox inherits all the features of AnyDVD and AnyDVD HD.
However, AnyDVD or AnyDVD HD is really limited. It just removes the DVD and Bluray copy protections and makes copy-free ISO or folder of the original disc. And it only works on Windows. If you want an alternative to AnyDVD HD, here it is.
Hunk's Recommendations: Lists of 2023 Best Tools to Easily Rip Bluray and DVDs
There are quite a lot of programs that can rip and convert Bluray and DVDs. I’m glad to recommend some and suggest you guys have a trial first to see if it is the very one for you.
All programs are fully compatible with the latest OS like Windows 11 and macOS 13 Ventura. Importantly, they are compatible with Silicon MACs.
Leawo is powerful in multimedia solutions, and they developed all its programs into one program called Leawo Prof. Media. And the Bluray ripper and DVD ripper are part of it. Leawo Bluray Ripper is my recommendation for both Windows and Mac users, and I’d like to rate it as the best tool to easily rip and convert protected/homemade DVDs, like those from Disney, Beachbody Cize, to iPhone/iPad/Apple TV, Samsung Galaxy S9/S9 Plus, or rip directly to iTunes. Leawo DVD Ripper is also good to go, but please note it is only for DVDs.
There are other functions in Leawo’s all-in-one solution. I have reviews or user guides of Leawo’s other functions. Check the links to see details:
You can visit here for details, giveaways, and a user guide on Leawo products. And you can download a free trial via the below buttons! If you are interested in the full version, don’t miss the discount!
VideoByte BD-DVD Ripper (PC & Mac)
VideoByte BD-DVD Ripper is the all-in-one tool to rip both DVDs and Blu-ray for you. You can use the best Blu-ray ripper to digitize homemade and commercial Blu-ray/DVD discs, for it can bypass various protections including ARccOS, CPRM, AACS, BD+, Cinavia, etc. What’s more, as the best ripper for Mac & Windows, VideoByte BD-DVD Ripper offers 300+ output formats to match most devices, and you have no need to worry about output compatibility. The whole ripping task though seemed complex, only requires 3 steps to finish, which won’t waste your time and is totally beginner-friendly.
It’s worth free downloading and trying this amazing DVD & Blu-ray ripper now. If you want to activate its full function and enjoy all amazing features to rip DVDs and Blu-rays, you won’t miss the 30% discount below!
MacX DVD Ripper Pro is also an excellent DVD ripping solution from Digiarty Inc. While WinX DVD Ripper Platinum is for Windows, MacX DVD Ripper Pro is specially designed for Mac. The latest update is fully compatible with Apple’s new macOS 13 Ventura and the new ARM-based Silicon MACs.
I’d like to recommend MacX DVD Ripper Pro for Mac users as it supports various DVD copy protections and rips them to different video or audio formats to meet different people’s needs. The UI is clean, and it is easy to use.
AnyMP4 is also recommended as it is rich in its own features like ripping SBS 3D Bluray DVD to true 3D MP4, MKV, splitting DVDs into chapters, compressing Bluray and DVD to multiple audio tracks so you can switch between them.
It can be a good alternative to users who own Wondershare, WinXDVD, Xilisoft, Sothink, which does not support Bluray or protected Blu-rays. However, please note, AnyMP4 Bluray Ripper is only for Bluray, and the AnyMP4 DVD ripper only for DVDs.
WonderFox DVD Ripper Pro is believed to be one of the best MakeMKV, Handbrake alternative, and WinX DVD Ripper, Aimersoft alternative on Windows. As tested, it is the fastest DVD ripper that helps me to rip protected DVDs from BBC, Beachbody, and Disney like COCO.
WonderFox DVD Ripper Pro is recommended because it offers abundant profiles for DVD ripping. You will see it is updated fluently to support the latest copy protection continuously.
And, if you are looking for the fastest DVD ripper, I’d like to recommend you guys to try WonderFox DVD Ripper Pro as an alternative, the fastest ripping software, with its feature of ripping DVDs to any format and it, is able to make an ISO file just with menus like the original.
Besides, I have an extraordinary Wonderfox DVD Ripper Pro offer for just $24.95, while it is $29.95 on the official site. You save $5 more with the below buy link:
I must admit that DVDFab is one of the best DVD and Bluray rippers worldwide because it does great jobs in Bluray and DVD ripping, copying, and creating.
For the DVD ripper, it supports all DVD copy protections like CSS and Region code. It has excellent features because I can always rip DVDs with forced subtitles and customized file names. Also, if you don’t want the commentary track in DVD ripping, it’s easy for DVDFab to turn it on and off.
DVDFab Bluray Ripper is super powerful in Blu-ray ripping and supports all Blu-ray protections, including AACS, Blu-ray region code, etc. And, it is able to remux Bluray to MKV, MP4, or M2TS with its passthrough profiles, meaning you won’t lose any quality in ripping.
For more details on DVDFab, you can visit my category for DVDFab here. If you want to rip Bluray or DVDs to the hard drive in MP4/MKV, iPhone/iPad, etc., get DVDFab here:
I am sure you will be impressed by its advanced settings:
Redfox AnyDVD and AnyDVD HD
- Available: Windows
- Output: ISO, Blu-ray/DVD Folder
It seems not many people know AnyDVD anymore. Actually, it is super-powerful in decrypting any Blu-ray or DVD copy protection, as the name suggests. It thoroughly deserves the title of “Best Blu-ray DVD Ripper” in this post. However, it’s really limited. With AnyDVD or AnyDVD HD, you can also decrypt your disc, either Blu-ray or DVD, to your hard drive, in ISO or Blu-ray/DVD folder that is no longer protected.
The point is, we need MP4 or other video formats much more over ISO or the folder, and we will have to re-rip unencrypted ISO or folder to whatever we need.
Also, note that AnyDVD is for DVDs, and AnyDVD HD is for Blu-ray.
VLC is one of my favor media players and it works great in video and DVD playback. And, I mainly use it for finding the right title for encrypted DVDs for better ripping. However, when it comes to DVD ripping with VLC, it is pretty average. And, truthfully, I dislike it as I continued receiving the error notice below.
You may end up with a corrupted file that is completely unplayable if you choose to overwrite it. I had to force close it with Task Manager.
What are ChatGPT's recommendations?
If you ask ChatGPT “Top Bluray DVD Rippers that can Easily Rip Your DVDs & Blu-Rays On Windows and macOS”, you get the below answer that almost matches my recommendations. Don’t ask it the best ones. It will explain it does not provide opinions or recommendations about what is the “best”.
You should always note that ChatGPT’s answers are not accurate. For example, in this top Blu-ray DVD ripper topic, ChatGPT is wrong about MacX DVD Ripper and WinX DVD Ripper ripping Blu-rays. Actually, they do not. Also, Handbrake does not rip encrypted discs.
Which do you think is the best Bluray DVD ripping solution on PC and Mac? Name it in the comments, please! I’d like to see what you think about them!